PingKit Agent vs NetAlertX
Both run on a Raspberry Pi, a NAS or a Linux computer that stays on, both are free to run, and both tell you when a new device joins your network. NetAlertX is open source with a full web dashboard. PingKit Agent for Docker and Raspberry Pi is a closed agent with open interfaces and a native iPhone app. Here is where each one wins, with NetAlertX's side checked on November 11, 2026.
PingKit for iPhone pairs with the agent. All 19 tools are free. No ads, no account.
Short version. NetAlertX is the better pick if you want a web dashboard, plugins, SNMP and router imports, and open source. If you want the alert on your iPhone as a real push, an outage log that says where the fault looks to be, and an agent that asks for no privilege beyond the host's network, PingKit Agent for Docker and Raspberry Pi is. Full disclosure: I build PingKit, so weigh that, and read NetAlertX's own pages before you decide.
Feature by Feature
| Capability | PingKit Agent for Docker and Raspberry Pi | NetAlertX |
|---|---|---|
| Price to run | Free | Free |
| Source | Closed agent; open interfaces: a local API, MQTT and webhooks | Open source, GPL-3.0 |
| Runs on | A Linux computer or NAS with Docker (amd64 or arm64), a 64-bit Raspberry Pi 4 or 5, or Home Assistant | Docker on the host network, with installation guides for several platforms, Home Assistant among them |
| Privileges in Docker | The host network only: no added capabilities, non-root, read-only file system, no raw socket | The host network plus NET_RAW, NET_ADMIN and NET_BIND_SERVICE, in its sample docker run |
| Interface | Read-only pages on the device, in 27 languages; settings live on the iPhone | A full web interface (its README names Chrome and Firefox) |
| A native iPhone app with push | Yes, PingKit; the push needs Guardian | Not mentioned in its README or documentation |
| Alerts to your own services | Free: ntfy, Telegram, Discord, Pushover, a signed webhook, and apprise-api for everything else | More than 80 services through Apprise, plus native Pushsafer, Pushover and NTFY publishers and webhooks |
| Internet outage log | Built in: Internet Down after three failed checks in a row, dated to the first, with where the fault looks to be; an Internet Outage Report for your ISP with Guardian | Through its Internet check (INTRNT) plugin |
| Speed tests | A daily test from the device, which you can set to manual or off | Through its Internet speedtest (INTRSPD) plugin |
| Home Assistant | Runs as a Home Assistant app; the internet, device counts and each device as entities over MQTT, with nothing to type when Mosquitto is installed | Feeds devices into Home Assistant, with an MQTT publisher plugin; its Home Assistant add-on is in a community repository (alexbelgium/hassio-addons) |
| Phones on private Wi-Fi addresses | Asks, with the evidence, whether it is a device it already knows | Recognises a private address by its pattern; its documentation advises turning private addresses off on your own devices |
| Router imports, SNMP | No | Yes: an SNMP router import, Pi-hole and generic DHCP lease imports, a UniFi controller import |
| Account | None: an 8-character pairing code from your iPhone | None |
NetAlertX's side from its README on GitHub and its documentation, including the Random MAC page, checked November 11, 2026. PingKit Agent's side from its README.
Where NetAlertX Wins
- Open source. NetAlertX is GPL-3.0: you can read, change and build every line. PingKit Agent is closed; you check what it does through its published egress list, signed images and open interfaces, not its source.
- A full web dashboard. Devices, their details, a network view, presence and settings, all in the browser. PingKit Agent's own pages are read-only; settings live on the iPhone.
- Imports and plugins. NetAlertX reads your router over SNMP, imports Pi-hole and DHCP leases and a UniFi controller, and adds features as plugins. PingKit Agent finds devices itself and imports nothing.
- More notification services. Apprise reaches more than 80. PingKit Agent covers five directly and leaves the rest to apprise-api.
Where PingKit Agent Wins
- The alert on your iPhone. PingKit is a native iPhone app. With Guardian, every alert arrives as a push, an outage gets a Live Activity, and the dashboard shows devices, outages, loss and latency and speed tests. Guardian is $2.99 a month or $24.99 a year on iPhone, with a 1-week free trial.
- Fewer privileges. The agent asks for the host's network and nothing more: no added capabilities, a non-root user, a read-only file system, and no raw socket. That matters on a NAS that also holds your files.
- Outages you can prove. An outage log is built in, not a plugin. While something is wrong the agent checks your router, the first hop past it and DNS, and says which looks broken, with honest time bounds. The Internet Outage Report (Guardian) turns that into something to send your provider. The dated log is what an ISP takes seriously.
- Phones on private addresses. A phone whose private Wi-Fi address changes looks new to most monitors. PingKit asks whether it is the device that just went quiet, with the evidence, instead of announcing a stranger.
- A silent monitor gets noticed. If the whole line drops, the agent cannot send anything. With Guardian, PingKit's server notices the agent has gone quiet and tells your iPhone the internet looks down at home within about three minutes.
If PingKit Ends
A closed agent is a fair worry, so here is our continuity pledge, written on November 10, 2026: the agent keeps working on your network without PingKit's server, its pages, its alerts to your own services and its Home Assistant entities included. If PingKit ever ends, a final build removes the dependency on PingKit's server, so the agent you run keeps running.
And Pi.Alert?
NetAlertX credits pucherot as the original creator of Pi.Alert, and leiweibau's Pi.Alert is still maintained, under GPL-3.0 (last updated October 16, 2026, checked November 11, 2026). It has a web interface, tells you when an unknown device appears or a known one goes offline, and can send Wake-on-LAN. The trade against PingKit Agent is the same as NetAlertX's: open source and a full web interface on one side, a native iPhone app and no added privileges on the other.
Which Should You Choose?
- You want open source, a full web dashboard, or imports from your router, Pi-hole or UniFi: NetAlertX.
- You want the alert as a push on your iPhone, with a dashboard there: PingKit Agent for Docker and Raspberry Pi. Install steps.
- Your monitor is a Raspberry Pi: the Raspberry Pi guide covers a 64-bit Pi 4 or 5 from first hour to first day. PingKit Agent refuses a 32-bit system.
- You want both: NetAlertX for the dashboard and PingKit Agent for the iPhone. We have not tested the two on one device; the questions below say what to check.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is NetAlertX free?
Yes. NetAlertX is open source under GPL-3.0 and free to run. PingKit Agent for Docker and Raspberry Pi is free to run too, with its own pages, its alerts to your ntfy, Telegram, Discord, Pushover or webhook, and its Home Assistant entities; only the push to PingKit on your iPhone and the iPhone dashboard need PingKit Guardian.
Does PingKit Agent need NET_RAW or NET_ADMIN?
No. It needs the host's network to read the neighbour table and hear Bonjour and UPnP announcements, and nothing else: no added capabilities, a read-only file system, a non-root user, and no raw socket ever. NetAlertX's sample docker run adds NET_RAW, NET_ADMIN and NET_BIND_SERVICE on the host network.
Does NetAlertX have an iPhone app?
Its README and documentation do not mention a native app, as of November 11, 2026; you use its web interface in a browser and its alerts arrive through the services you connect. PingKit Agent pairs with PingKit, a native iPhone app, and with Guardian sends every alert as a push.
Can I run NetAlertX and PingKit Agent on the same Raspberry Pi?
We have not tested the two side by side. Both use the host's network. PingKit Agent's status page is on port 7474 and its iPhone connection on 7475, and it peaked at about 55 MB of memory in a 24-hour test, so check those ports are free and watch the Pi's memory.
What about Pi.Alert?
Pi.Alert is the project NetAlertX credits, with pucherot as its original creator. leiweibau's Pi.Alert is still maintained, under GPL-3.0, with a web interface, alerts for unknown devices and devices going offline, and Wake-on-LAN. Everything this page says about NetAlertX's place against PingKit Agent applies to it as well: open source and a full web interface on one side, a native iPhone app and no added privileges on the other.
More Comparisons
- PingKit Agent vs Fing Agent
- PingKit vs Uptime Kuma
- PingKit vs Pi-hole
- PingKit vs Fingbox
- Get an Alert When a New Device Joins Your WiFi (2026)
- Fing Agent Alternatives (2026): Pi, NAS, Docker or a Mac You Own
- Every PingKit comparison
Pair your first agent
Download PingKit, open Agents and tap Add an Agent for your code. Running the agent is free; alerts on your iPhone need Guardian, with a 1-week free trial.
Download PingKit Free