PingKit Agent vs Fing Agent
Both watch your home network from a device that stays on: a Raspberry Pi, a NAS or a Docker host. Fing Agent needs a paid Fing plan and a Fing account. PingKit Agent for Docker and Raspberry Pi is free to run and needs no account. Here is where each one wins, with Fing's side checked on November 9, 2026, and its prices, agent page and Home Assistant integration again on November 11, 2026.
PingKit for iPhone pairs with the agent. All 19 tools are free. No ads, no account.
Short version. If you want to block devices, set access schedules, buy a Pi that comes ready to plug in, or monitor from Windows, Fing is the better fit. If you already have a Raspberry Pi, a NAS or a Linux computer that stays on and want to be told when the internet drops or a new device joins, without a subscription to run the agent and without an account, PingKit Agent for Docker and Raspberry Pi is. Full disclosure: I build PingKit, so weigh that, and check Fing's current pages before you decide.
Feature by Feature
| Capability | PingKit Agent for Docker and Raspberry Pi | Fing Agent |
|---|---|---|
| Runs on | A Linux computer with Docker (amd64 or arm64), a NAS through its container manager, a 64-bit Raspberry Pi 4 or 5, or Home Assistant | Raspberry Pi, Linux servers, NAS through container managers, and Docker |
| Windows and Mac | Not the agent; a Mac uses the separate PingKit Mac Agent, while the Mac is awake | Fing Desktop, a separate app |
| Account required | No: an 8-character pairing code from your iPhone | Yes, a Fing account |
| Price to run the agent | Free | A paid plan: Premium $8.99 a month or $79.99 a year on fing.com, $7.99 or $69.99 in Fing's iPhone app (checked November 11, 2026) |
| Alerts on your phone | In PingKit on iPhone with Guardian, $2.99 a month or $24.99 a year, with a Live Activity during an outage and a widget; free to your own ntfy, Telegram, Discord, Pushover or webhook. Pairing, the agent's status and the last 24 hours of its timeline on your iPhone are free | In the Fing app, with the paid plan |
| Agents per plan | One with Guardian; up to five with Guardian Plus | Two with Premium; three or more with Professional ($19.99 a month) |
| Internet outage log | Yes, dated to the first failed check, with where the fault looks to be; an Internet Outage Report for your ISP with Guardian | A timeline: today only on Free, full on Premium |
| Actions from your phone, away from home | Wake-on-LAN, ping and a scan through the relay, with Guardian | Not compared |
| New devices | Reported after a first day of learning; asks before treating a phone on a new private address as new | Alerts when a new device joins |
| Your device list | Stays on the agent; your iPhone reads it directly, and names never rest on PingKit's servers | Syncs with your Fing account |
| Block devices, access schedules | No | Yes |
| Ready-made Raspberry Pi kit | No; you install it on a Pi you have | Yes, sold by Vilros and Pimoroni |
| Home Assistant | Runs as a Home Assistant app; devices and internet state as entities over MQTT, free | An official integration (Home Assistant 2025.11, local polling), with a Fing Agent's Local API |
| Privileges in Docker | None added: non-root, every capability dropped, read-only file system, host network | Not compared |
| 32-bit Raspberry Pi OS | No, 64-bit only | Not compared |
Fing's side from fing.com/agent and fing.com/pricing, and the Home Assistant Fing integration, checked November 9, 2026; prices, the agent page and the integration checked again on November 11, 2026. Fing's pages do not list the kit's price. Prices are in US dollars.
Where Fing Wins
- Blocking and schedules. Fing Premium can block a device, block unknown devices automatically and set access schedules. PingKit Agent does none of this; it watches and tells you.
- A Pi that arrives ready. Fing sells a Raspberry Pi kit with the agent preinstalled, through Vilros in North America and Pimoroni elsewhere. With PingKit you bring the Pi and run one command.
- Windows. Fing Desktop covers a Windows PC. PingKit's agents run on Linux and on a Mac.
- Maturity and recognition. Fing has been identifying devices for over a decade and its device database is the largest in the category. Premium also covers two networks on one plan.
Where PingKit Agent Wins
- Free to run, no account. The agent, its local status page and its alerts to your own ntfy, Telegram, Discord, Pushover or webhook cost nothing. Only the iPhone side, the relay and the dashboard, is paid, and it funds the one person who builds PingKit.
- Outages you can prove. Internet Down is recorded after three failed checks in a row, dated to the first, with whether your router still answered. During a full outage, PingKit's server notices the agent has gone quiet and, with Guardian, tells your iPhone "Internet looks down at home" within about three minutes. The dated log is what an ISP takes seriously.
- Phones on private addresses. A phone whose private Wi-Fi address changes looks like a new device to most monitors. PingKit asks whether it is the device that just went quiet, with the evidence, instead of announcing a stranger.
- Your device list stays home. The iPhone reads it from the agent, on your network or through a VPN that routes to it. PingKit's server carries alerts only.
- Price of the phone alerts. Guardian is $2.99 a month or $24.99 a year on iPhone, about a third of Fing Premium, and it also unlocks the rest of PingKit's monitoring on iPhone and Mac.
Moving From a Fingbox
Fingbox is no longer sold, and Fing moved its always-on monitoring into Fing Agent and Fing Desktop. If your Fingbox did the watching and you never used its blocking, a Raspberry Pi or a NAS running PingKit Agent replaces that part, free to run. If blocking was the point, look at Fing Premium or your router's own controls. PingKit vs Fingbox covers the box itself.
Which Should You Choose?
- You want to block devices or schedule a child's access: Fing Premium, or your router.
- You want a Pi that arrives ready, or you monitor from Windows: Fing.
- You already have a Raspberry Pi, a NAS or a Linux computer that stays on, and want outage and new-device alerts without an account: PingKit Agent for Docker and Raspberry Pi. Install steps.
- You have a Mac that stays awake and nothing else: the Mac angle is covered here.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a free alternative to Fing Agent?
Yes. PingKit Agent for Docker and Raspberry Pi runs on the same kinds of device, a Raspberry Pi, a NAS or a Linux computer with Docker, and running it is free, with no account. Its alerts in PingKit on your iPhone need PingKit Guardian, $2.99 a month or $24.99 a year on iPhone; alerts to your own ntfy, Telegram, Discord, Pushover or webhook are free. Fing Agent needs a paid Fing plan.
Can PingKit Agent block devices like Fing?
No. PingKit Agent watches your network and tells you what changed; it does not block devices or set access schedules. If blocking is what you need, Fing Premium or your router does it.
Does PingKit Agent run on Windows?
No. It runs on Linux: a Linux computer or NAS with Docker, a 64-bit Raspberry Pi 4 or 5, or Home Assistant. Docker Desktop on Windows and macOS cannot give it your devices. On Windows, Fing Desktop is the option; on a Mac, the PingKit Mac Agent watches your network while the Mac is awake.
Does PingKit Agent need an account?
No. You pair it with the 8-character code PingKit shows on your iPhone under Agents, which works once, for 10 minutes. Your iPhone reads the device list from the agent directly, and device names never rest on PingKit's servers.
Can I run Fing Agent and PingKit Agent on the same Raspberry Pi?
We have not tested the two side by side. Both use the host's network to see your devices; PingKit Agent's status page is on port 7474 and it runs as its own unprivileged user. If you try both, watch the Pi's memory: PingKit Agent stayed under 55 MB in a 24-hour test.
More Comparisons
- PingKit vs Fingbox
- PingKit vs Fing
- PingKit vs Pi-hole
- PingKit vs Uptime Kuma
- Fing Agent Alternatives (2026): Pi, NAS, Docker or a Mac You Own
- Fingbox Alternatives (2026): Software Options Without the Hardware
- Every PingKit comparison
Pair your first agent
Download PingKit, open Agents and tap Add an Agent for your code. Running the agent is free; alerts on your iPhone need Guardian, with a 1-week free trial.
Download PingKit Free